Michael – I absolutely love this song! He rocked it and I don’t find he had pitch problems like Randy said. I do agree that he does blues better, but it was good.
Syesha – I didn’t care for this song, but yes, she does have a great voice. It was a good choice for her and she even hit that high note. Good for her, but once again, for some reason I’m not as Randy says “feelin’ her.” I do agree that she had no emotion or passion with the song.
Jason – Ya’ll know I like him … Ok, I liked it. It was different. His voice sounded great and playing the ukelele (not sure if that’s how you spell it) was cool. I thought it was good enough for me to put up for you to see again.
Kristy – A little pitchy as usual. Actually as we’re watching, La Petite Belle said, “Fast forward this one.” I guess that pretty much sums it up. I don’t think she was as good as the judges said. Come on America, it’s time for her to go.
David C. – I’m a little surprised because he’s done so awesome lately, but he didn’t start out too great. I’d never heard of this song or band and didn’t care for the song at all. It was probably the worst he’s done, but he’s still pretty awesome.
Carly – You know … she is my favorite! But tonight, this was not a good song for her. Her voice is amazing anyway!
David A. – It started out OK, but he did some great runs on the end. I wasn’t crazy about the song and him at the piano.
Brooke – I like her a lot too. She even sounds like Carole King to me. Her voice is very soothing. She can’t do all those runs and everything, but actually I would rather listen to her than someone who is singing all over the place. It wasn’t awesome, but it was still good.
NOTE: I’VE BEEN READING A BUNCH OF OTHER POSTS ABOUT LAST NIGHT AND SOME PEOPLE ARE SAYNG CARLY SHOULD GO HOME. UM … HELLO … PEOPLE, SHE CAN SING! SHE DEFINITELY SHOULD NOT BE GOING HOME JUST BECAUSE SHE HAD AN OFF-NIGHT! DON’T WORRY … I’M NOT UPSET.
i can’t wait to watch it! My husband always fast forwards through Kristy’s songs, too:) Neither of us like country, and we especially do not like country sung average at best.
I agree with you on pretty much all of it again. I’m not a big fan of David A., but liked how he did tonight. And I really was expecting more out of David C. and Carly… I can’t see either one going home though – they’re still awesome. 🙂
I don’t watch American Idol, I may be the only person in America who doesn’t… but anyways, the Jason guy looks like a not so attractive young lady.
That is my not so nice comment for the day (ha! as if that’s the only one)
I love Jason. I agree Carly should not go home, especially before someone like Kristy Lee (though I think she is a nice girl she can’t stand up against Carly.)
julie